You Say You Love Freedom—But Only When It’s Convenient
Feaure Photo by Sasha Freemind on Unsplash
“Freedom” is the rallying cry for a lot of red state rhetoric—freedom from taxes, from mandates, from federal overreach. But when you look closer, that love of liberty often stops the moment someone else’s freedom doesn’t fit the conservative mold. Want to marry who you love, read a banned book, or control your own body? Suddenly, that freedom comes with conditions.
Blue states get dragged for their regulations—but in practice, they often offer more personal freedom, not less. Here’s what that really looks like.
Table of Contents
Freedom to Marry, Exist, and Be Seen
As of 2024, over 30 red or purple states have introduced or passed anti-LGBTQ+ legislation, including laws targeting drag shows, trans healthcare, and even same-sex parents. Meanwhile, blue states like Oregon, Washington, and California have strengthened protections for LGBTQ+ people—ensuring access to healthcare, education, and public spaces without discrimination (source: ACLU, 2024).
📍 GET THE ULTIMATE PNW MAP 🗺️
Get our curated list of the best adventures, things to do, and places to grab a brew loaded onto your maps with just two clicks!
✅ Waterfalls ✅ Hikes ✅ Viewpoints
✅ Craft breweries ✅ National Parks ✅ 1400+ Pins
If you claim to stand for “freedom,” you can’t carve out exceptions based on gender identity or who someone loves. Freedom is either for everyone—or it’s just branding.
Freedom of Speech—Unless It’s a Book You Don’t Like
Book bans are spreading fastest in red states. According to PEN America, over 3,000 book bans were enacted in 2023, most in states like Texas, Florida, Missouri, and Tennessee. Many target books about race, gender, or sexuality—often removing them from public school shelves with no formal review.
In contrast, blue states have introduced legislation to protect library access and academic freedom. California and Oregon passed state-level laws ensuring school districts can’t ban books based solely on content related to identity.
Freedom of speech shouldn’t end at the school library door.
Freedom of Religion—But Only Yours
Red states often tout religious freedom—until it’s used by someone outside the dominant Christian framework. Bans on Muslim head coverings, restrictions on indigenous ceremonies, and the absence of legal protections for non-Christian spiritual practices show a selective application of this “freedom.”
Meanwhile, blue states offer broader protection under the First Amendment for diverse belief systems—including protections for atheist, Wiccan, Jewish, and Sikh communities in workplaces and schools. Real freedom of religion isn’t about dominance—it’s about choice.
Freedom of Movement—Unless You Need Reproductive Care
Since the fall of Roe v. Wade, 21 states have enacted near-total abortion bans or heavy restrictions (source: Guttmacher Institute, 2024). In several cases, laws now attempt to criminalize out-of-state travel for reproductive care, effectively limiting the freedom to move between states.
Blue states like California, Washington, and New York have become “sanctuary states” for reproductive rights—offering not only legal abortion access, but legal protection for those traveling from elsewhere.
If a woman can’t cross a state line without being surveilled or sued, are we really still calling that freedom?
Freedom to Learn and Live Without Fear
Students in red states are increasingly restricted in what they can learn about U.S. history, race, gender, and civil rights. Many schools have pulled AP African American Studies courses, restricted DEI initiatives, or passed “Don’t Say Gay”–style legislation.
Blue states are going in the opposite direction: expanding curriculum, supporting inclusive education, and protecting teacher speech. True freedom means giving young people access to the full spectrum of knowledge—not rewriting history to avoid discomfort.
If Freedom Only Works for Some, It’s Not Freedom
You can’t champion liberty with one hand while using the other to censor, surveil, or legislate someone else’s choices. Red state freedom often sounds great in theory—but in practice, it’s riddled with exceptions.
If you want the freedom to live your life without interference, blue states may not be perfect—but they’re far more consistent about actually delivering it.
Sending to my friends! Thank you!!!